Thursday, November 19, 2026Toronto, ON
The Toronto Journal
Canada

Toronto Widower Urges MPs to Rethink Bill That Would Permanently Bar MAID for Mental Illness Alone

David Slater says his wife, who had treatment-resistant depression, was ineligible for an assisted death. Justice Minister Sean Fraser says he chose caution without medical consensus; the bill must pass by March 17.

By Journal Staff ·
The Centre Block of Canada's Parliament in Ottawa, a long Gothic Revival sandstone building with copper-roofed towers, and the Peace Tower with a clock and Canadian flag rising from its centre under a deep blue sky
The Centre Block and Peace Tower on Parliament Hill, Ottawa (file photo, 2013). Photo: Saffron Blaze / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0 (cropped).

This story discusses suicide. If you or someone you know is thinking about suicide, support is available 24-7 by calling or texting 988, Canada's national suicide prevention helpline.

A Toronto man whose wife died by suicide last month is asking members of Parliament to rethink a federal bill that would permanently keep people whose only underlying condition is a mental illness from receiving medical assistance in dying (MAID), The Canadian Press reported on Thursday.

David Slater says his wife, Diane McDowell, a 71-year-old retired litigation lawyer, lived with depression for decades. She wanted a medically assisted death but was not eligible, and she died on Oct. 25, according to the CP report. About six weeks earlier, Slater told CP, she said to him: "I don't want to die, but I don't want to live like this." He added: "And that's MAID in a nutshell."

What Bill C-41 would do

Justice Minister Sean Fraser introduced the Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act, Bill C-41, on Oct. 27. According to the Justice Department's backgrounder, it would allow advance requests for MAID where eligibility criteria and safeguards are met and a province or territory has its own legislation in place, and it would not move ahead with expanding MAID on the basis of a mental illness.

Under current law, that expansion is scheduled to take effect on March 17, 2027, after Parliament twice pushed it back. The Globe and Mail reported that the bill must pass the House of Commons and the Senate and receive royal assent by that date to stop it. As of Nov. 4, the bill was at second reading in the House, according to openparliament.ca.

In June, a special joint committee of MPs and senators recommended indefinitely excluding people whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness. When he announced the decision in October, Fraser pointed to concerns about people living in communities with inadequate access to mental-health services and a lack of consensus over when a mental illness is incurable.

'No stone left unturned'

Slater told CP that McDowell had kept her depression in remission for years with medication and therapy. After she tapered off her medication in retirement, the illness returned, and treatments her doctors tried over the following years, including transcranial magnetic stimulation, electroconvulsive therapy and ketamine, did not help, he said.

She spent time in the psychiatric ward at Toronto General Hospital and about nine weeks at Homewood Health Centre in Guelph, according to the report. "There was no stone left unturned," Slater said. He told CP he would have supported her if she had pursued MAID; his own father received MAID at 89 after a stroke.

Slater said he knows his wife's life would have ended either way, but that with MAID "the dignity with which she lived her life would have been maintained," CP reported.

Fraser: 'preserve life where possible'

Fraser told CP he read McDowell's obituary and was moved, and that he had recently lost a childhood friend who struggled with mental illness for more than 20 years. But he said he had to decide "in the absence of consensus from the medical community" and chose caution because the decision to end one's life is permanent, according to the report.

"You do your best to, in the presence of a wide range of opinions, take decisions that have the potential to preserve life where possible, without being inconsiderate towards people who don't see a path for themselves," Fraser said. He said many psychiatrists told him there was no way to tell whether someone could get better with the right treatment, and that he had spoken to people who would not be alive today if MAID had been available to them.

Some experts, meanwhile, have warned that restricting access will lead some people to die by suicide instead, CP reported.

A vote for the MP next door

Liberal MP Robert Oliphant, McDowell's neighbour of 16 years, spoke at her funeral on Nov. 7. Oliphant co-chaired a parliamentary committee that made recommendations on MAID in 2016, and he told CP the vote on C-41 won't be straightforward because supporting it would close the door on mental illness while opening one to advance requests for people with dementia and similar conditions. "I will have to decide on where ultimately I come down on it," he said.

Sources: The Canadian Press via CityNews (Nov. 12) · Department of Justice Canada (Bill C-41 backgrounder) · Health Canada (MAID legislation) · The Globe and Mail · CBC News · openparliament.ca (Bill C-41)