Thursday, November 19, 2026Toronto, ON
The Toronto Journal
Politics

S&P Puts Ontario on Negative Outlook, Warning of a One-in-Three Chance of a Credit Downgrade

The agency kept the province's AA- rating but says tariff-driven deficits and debt exceeded its expectations. Moody's, Fitch and DBRS still have Ontario on stable.

By Journal Staff ·
The curved, pale stone facade of the Frost Building on Queen's Park Crescent in Toronto under a clear blue sky, with the Whitney Block's Gothic-style tower and downtown towers behind bare trees
The Frost Building (right) and the Whitney Block, Ontario government offices at Queen's Park, Toronto (file photo). Photo: Maksim Sokolov (maxergon.com) / Wikimedia Commons, 2019, CC BY-SA 4.0 (cropped).

One of the world's big credit rating agencies has put Ontario on notice. On Nov. 10, S&P Global Ratings revised the province's outlook to negative from stable. It kept Ontario's 'AA-' long-term rating and its 'A-1+' short-term rating, and it also affirmed the 'AA-' rating on Ontario Electricity Financial Corp.

The change does not lower the rating. It is a warning: S&P says the negative outlook reflects at least a one-in-three chance that it could lower the rating in the next two years. The Trillium reported that a downgrade would likely mean higher borrowing costs for the province.

Why S&P moved

The agency points to the Ford government's response to U.S. trade policy. According to S&P, the steps Ontario took to cushion the economic impact of tariffs generated operating deficits and a rise in debt that exceeded its expectations. It said the province has been supporting affected businesses and workers through loans, strategic investments and corporate tax relief.

Those choices show up in the province's own numbers. The fall economic statement projects a $16.9-billion deficit in 2026–27, followed by deficits of $12.7 billion in 2027–28 and $6.7 billion in 2028–29 and a small $0.2-billion surplus in 2029–30. The Globe and Mail called that the fourth delay to a balanced budget since 2024, and S&P noted that the government has again postponed its timeline to balance. Finance Minister Peter Bethlenfalvy has pointed to U.S. tariffs as the main driver of the larger deficit.

The debt picture

S&P forecasts that Ontario's tax-supported debt, which includes direct debt, public-private partnership obligations and guarantees, will rise to approximately $590 billion by fiscal 2029. That would be 244 per cent of operating revenues, up from 240 per cent in fiscal 2026. The agency called the increase modest, but described the level as high compared with Canadian and global peers.

It also expects interest costs to climb to about 8.4 per cent of operating revenues, and deficits after capital spending to peak this fiscal year, which ends March 31, 2027, at about 16 per cent of total revenues. Ontario's capital plan totals more than $210 billion over 10 years.

What would trigger a downgrade, or undo the warning

S&P says a downgrade could come over the next one to two years amid persistent operating deficits, absent a credible path to restore fiscal balance in a timely manner. It would return the outlook to stable if the province narrows operating deficits to a balanced position, stabilizes after-capital deficits at about 10 per cent of total revenues and brings the debt burden below 240 per cent of operating revenues.

The report was not all bad news for Queen's Park. S&P's base case is still that deficits will narrow and Ontario will reach operating balance by fiscal 2029, and it said the government remains committed to closing budget gaps, largely through cost containment, with significant contingencies built into its plan. It continues to see the province's economic diversity and robust natural resource base as key credit strengths. It also said there could be upside to Ontario's 2026 growth relative to the 0.5 per cent the province assumed in its fiscal update.

The government's response and the other raters

The Ford government pledged to continue a "prudent" fiscal approach, The Trillium reported. In its Queen's Park Today newsletter, The Trillium quoted Brian Lewis, a former chief economist with the province, on how the finance minister may have taken the news: "No finance minister ever would view this as good news."

S&P is, for now, alone. The Ontario Financing Authority's ratings page shows Moody's (Aa3), Fitch (AA-) and Morningstar DBRS (AA) all with stable outlooks, confirmed in May and June of this year, while S&P's entry now reads AA- with a negative outlook as of Nov. 10, 2026.

Sources: S&P Global Ratings (Nov. 10 research update) · Ontario Financing Authority (credit ratings) · Ontario Fall Economic Statement 2026 · The Trillium · The Trillium (Queen's Park Today) · The Globe and Mail · Western Standard