Thursday, November 19, 2026Toronto, ON
The Toronto Journal
Entertainment

Toronto Crowns Its 'Nathanest Nathan': Law Student Wins the City's First Nathan Fielder Lookalike Contest

More than 200 people lined up at the Paradise Theatre on Bloor Street, where Jayden Daniels, 25, out-deadpanned the field through a Fielder walk, a business pitch and a conversation with an Elizabeth Holmes impersonator. Fielder himself did not show.

By Journal Staff ·
The tiled black facade and white marquee reading Paradise Cinema on a beige brick building on Bloor Street West in Toronto, with a black car passing in front
The Paradise Theatre at 1006 Bloor St. W., where Tuesday's contest was held (file photo, July 2011). Photo: William Mewes / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0 (cropped and resized).

Toronto finally has its own Nathan Fielder. It just isn't Nathan Fielder. On Tuesday night, a Paradise Theatre stage full of grey wigs, button-down shirts and blank stares produced a winner: Jayden Daniels, a 25-year-old law student from Toronto, who held his deadpan through the whole competition, CBC News reports.

It was billed as the city's first. TorontoToday says more than 200 people lined up outside the Bloorcourt Village venue for Toronto's first-ever Nathan Fielder lookalike contest. The Globe and Mail called it a sold-out event that left Bloor Street "awash with Nathan Fielders". The real one, a Canadian comedian and filmmaker, did not make an appearance.

Who put it on

The streaming service Mubi and Toronto's Bad Dog Theatre Company sponsored the night. According to TorontoToday, prizes included a one-year Mubi subscription and a comedy course. When CBC announced the contest earlier this month, it said entry would be free for contestants and spectators, first come, first served.

Comedian Andrew Phung, known for Kim's Convenience and Run the Burbs, hosted. Second City alum Hannah Spear played Elizabeth Holmes, the disgraced Theranos founder at the centre of Fielder's documentary You Can See Everything. Phung opened by calling Fielder "a cultural icon, a Canadian pop culture phenomenon and a graduate of one of Canada's top business schools with very good grades", a nod to the opening line of Nathan for You. CBC notes that Fielder did earn a business degree from the University of Victoria in 2005.

How the rounds went

TorontoToday counted 30 contestants. It says the first round judged resemblance and "aura" and eliminated four. The Globe put the field at 26 entrants. In round two, each remaining contestant did a "Fielder walk" across the stage while Shakira's Hips Don't Lie played, a reference to a viral dance Fielder did to the song in 2010. That round cut 15 more.

Next came a 30-second business pitch "Fielder-style", judged by Kelly White and Meagan Bianco, hosts of the Nathan for Us fan podcast. Technology sales professional David Papay used his time to promote his real indie band, Never Better. He told the room it had 250 Instagram followers and that "statistically, 40 of those are my mom's friends". Another contestant pitched a witness protection program for dogs that poo on neighbours' lawns. He was eliminated, but TorontoToday reports the judges brought him back after the audience demanded it.

In the final round, each finalist had a one-on-one conversation with Spear in character as Holmes. Both TorontoToday and the Globe say the winner was decided by audience applause. According to TorontoToday, Daniels was the only contestant who didn't break into a smile during that challenge. Papay finished second.

A reluctant Nathan

"There were some Nathan ringers out there," Daniels told CBC News. "I'm shocked and flattered that I won." He said friends kept sending him the event flyer until he signed up, and that he had already won two Halloween contests dressed as Fielder. Before the contest, though, he told TorontoToday he is "actually not a fan at all". He admitted he was partly joking: "I like him. It's just too cringe for me."

After the crowning, the audience watched the first episode of The Curse, the series Fielder made with Benny Safdie. CBC says it starts streaming on Mubi this week. Fielder lookalike contests have also been held in New York, Los Angeles and Sydney. Daniels said he would like to see more in Canadian cities such as Montreal and Hamilton, "but it was nice to have one in Toronto, with one of Canada's heroes." For one night, CBC noted, the city had its own "Nathanest Nathan," as social media users dubbed the winner.

Sources: CBC News (Nov. 18) · TorontoToday (Nov. 18) · The Globe and Mail (Nov. 18) · CBC News (contest announcement)