Thursday, November 19, 2026Toronto, ON
The Toronto Journal
Crime

Fake City Permits Posted as Trees Fell at Etobicoke Lot Tied to Developer Modcity, CBC Reports

Toronto says it never issued the permits for 65 Fortieth St. in Long Branch, where a white fir neighbours once saved was cut. Modcity, already facing tree bylaw charges, disputes any wrongdoing.

By Journal Staff ·
A painterly illustration of a freshly cut tree stump surrounded by sawdust and fir branches on the front lawn of a modest bungalow on a quiet residential street in late autumn
Illustration: The Toronto Journal (generated image; not a photograph of the events described).

A Toronto multiplex developer already facing tree bylaw charges is at the centre of new allegations in Etobicoke, where four trees were cut down at a Long Branch property and permits posted on site appear to have been fake, CBC Toronto reported Monday.

The trees came down at 65 Fortieth St. on Oct. 24, one day after the property changed hands, according to property records cited by CBC. The buyer was a company directed by two of Modcity's co-founders, Ron Sheinin and Rohan Sadana.

Permits the city says it never issued

CBC Toronto obtained photos of apparent removal permits for three trees in the backyard, which were posted at the property the day the trees were cut. The documents carried City of Toronto letterhead and listed the address, but the city confirmed it did not issue them.

Local councillor Amber Morley said that if the documents were forged, that would be a crime, and that it "needs to be fully investigated to the full extent of the law." Her office is working with city departments to explore options.

The city said it is investigating to determine if there were bylaw violations, and media relations manager Kayla Lewis said in an emailed statement that a violation could lead to prosecution. The CBC report does not say whether police have been asked to look at the permits.

Modcity disputes the allegations

Sheinin and Sadana did not answer detailed questions from CBC Toronto, including whether they posted or authorized the posting of fake permits or approved removing the trees without city approval. In an email, Sadana said they "strongly dispute" allegations of wrongdoing.

Several neighbours told CBC they saw Sheinin and Sadana at the property while the trees were being removed. A photo taken the same day shows a car parked across the street with a Modcity vanity licence plate, registered to a numbered company of which Sheinin is president and sole director, the broadcaster reported.

A tree the neighbourhood fought to save

One of the four was a white fir that towered above a two-bedroom bungalow and had been featured on neighbourhood walking tours. "It was the epitome of the perfect tree," neighbour Sherry McCutcheon told CBC. Randy McWatters, who said he had watched it grow for more than five decades, called its loss "disturbing".

The fir had survived an earlier fight. In 2018, a previous owner applied to sever the lot, tear down the house and build two new ones. The committee of adjustment approved the plan despite objections from the city's urban forestry department, and the city appealed to the Toronto Local Appeal Body on the grounds that the variances would require removing a healthy tree. The appeal succeeded, with a decision issued in 2022.

A pattern across the city

Long Branch is not the first neighbourhood to raise these concerns. As of early September, the city had 10 open investigations related to the company. That month, residents near 48 Ennerdale Rd., in the Dufferin Street and Rogers Road area, said about a dozen mature trees were cut on Aug. 22; Sadana told CBC then that "Modcity has no relationship to the Ennerdale property" beyond providing brokerage services.

In April, neighbours on Kirknewton Road in the Dufferin-Eglinton area said a Modcity executive and a worker began cutting trees with a chainsaw at about 11 p.m., and residents of Glenrose Avenue, near St. Clair Avenue and Mount Pleasant Road, said a worker there claimed to have city permits that city staff said had never been issued.

Modcity now faces four charges related to tree bylaw offences, which are before the courts, along with several noise bylaw charges. None of the allegations has been proven in court.

Why critics say fines aren't enough

The maximum fine is $100,000 per offence. But under provincial law, the city cannot deny a developer a building permit because of tree bylaw violations. Coun. Alejandra Bravo has called that "a massive gap in provincial legislation".

Danijela Puric-Mladenovic, an assistant professor of forestry at the University of Toronto, told CBC the potential fines aren't a strong enough deterrent compared with developer profits, and that replacement plantings "will never reach the canopy that we used to have".

Last year, the city asked the province to change the law so that breaking its tree bylaws would be grounds to refuse a building permit. The Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing had not responded to CBC Toronto's emails.

Sources: CBC News (Nov. 9) · CBC News (September) · CBC News (April)