Sunday, November 22, 2026Toronto, ON
The Toronto Journal
Editorial

Editorial: The TTC's New Board Should Open the Books on Its CEO's Consultant Contracts

Invoices show a U.K. firm billed about $830,000 for two months of work, above the CEO's $500,000 single-source limit. Lali deserves due process, but riders deserve to see the review, and the CEO shouldn't be the one who ordered it.

Editorial · By Journal Staff ·
A beige stone office tower with a TTC logo on its rooftop structure stands above Davisville subway yard, where a silver Toronto Rocket subway train curves along the tracks under a clear blue autumn sky
The W.C. McBrien Building, the TTC's head office above Davisville station, with Davisville Yard in the foreground (file photo, November 2014). Photo: Secondarywaltz / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 (cropped and resized).

Paul Ainslie had barely been named chair of the TTC board when he was asked about the agency's latest troubles. His answer was the right one. Reports of unsolicited contracts were “very concerning,” he said, and if one “was issued improperly or not according to the guidelines of the TTC, it'll be terminated.” Now the new board needs to make sure Torontonians can see the answers for themselves.

The questions come from two TorontoToday investigations. The first reported that CEO Mandeep Lali is under an external investigation over a complaint related to workplace conduct toward a staff member. The second reported that a U.K. consulting firm, Octa Partners, was incorporated the week before Lali took over and has since received at least two single-source contracts. None of these allegations has been proven, and Lali deserves, as Coun. Josh Matlow put it, an opportunity to “have his due process”. Ainslie, who sat on the panel that hired him, says Lali has helped lift morale. Fairness to the CEO and openness with the public are not in conflict.

The numbers that need explaining

The TTC's own rules let the CEO approve a single-source contract only up to a maximum project budget of $500,000; anything larger needs the board's prior approval. A TTC staff report from this spring confirms the CEO's single-source authority remained at a total of $500,000. Yet invoices obtained by TorontoToday show Octa billed the TTC about C$830,000 for work completed in February and March alone, with founder Satpal Loyal's all-in rate at about C$4,050 per day.

There may be an explanation. The board held a confidential discussion on asset management on Nov. 3, 2025, and the public does not know what was decided. What the public does know is that in April, Lali asked the board to let him approve single-source contracts up to a cumulative value of $5 million, and the request was deferred and has not been re-tabled. The TTC's webpage for non-competitive contracts doesn't list a single contract, according to TorontoToday. When asked, a spokesperson said contract details “are considered proprietary and confidential” while also insisting “all contracts are awarded within TTC guidelines.” Riders are being asked to take that on faith.

Don't repeat the Leary playbook

Toronto has been here before. In October 2023 the board launched a workplace misconduct inquiry into former CEO Rick Leary, who denied all allegations and resigned months later. The results of the Leary investigation were never made public. Personnel findings involve privacy rights, and some details should stay confidential. But the public deserves at least to know whether a complaint was substantiated and what the board did about it.

The contracting questions are different. They are about public money, not anyone's private life. In response to TorontoToday, the TTC said the CEO has directed an external independent review of procurement from the last two years, with results “provided to the Board in due course.” A review of contracts the CEO signed should not be commissioned by the CEO. The board should take ownership of it, or hand it to the city's auditor general. Coun. Stephen Holyday has already said he expects the city and TTC board to use their own “internal audit process” for these expenditures. Whatever the review finds should be released in public session, along with the total value of every Octa contract and how each was approved.

Why it matters now

The stakes go beyond one consultant. The TTC's $3.0 billion 2026 operating budget leans on provincial New Deal money that ends March 31, 2027, which leaves an incremental base pressure of approximately $379 million in 2027 if nothing replaces it. Premier Doug Ford has said “there's no 2.0”. Ainslie says the TTC's biggest problems “all come down to money,” and he wants a better deal from Ottawa and Queen's Park.

That case is much harder to make if the agency can't show where its money already goes. Mayor Olivia Chow has said she will leave it to the new TTC commission to handle the details. The new board's first job should be simple: publish what was spent, explain who approved it, and finish both reviews in the open.

Sources: TorontoToday (Nov. 18): Octa consultant invoices · TorontoToday (Nov. 13): CEO workplace conduct investigation · TorontoToday (Nov. 19): Chow defers to new TTC board · CP24 (Nov. 19): Ainslie on TTC leadership · TTC: Updates to the CEO's Delegated Authority (2026 staff report) · TTC: Intergovernmental Funding, 2026 Operating Budget · TorontoToday (Nov. 6): Ford rules out New Deal 2.0