Thursday, November 19, 2026Toronto, ON
The Toronto Journal
Editorial

Editorial: Toronto's Backyard Homes Are Finally Catching On. Now City Hall Should Stop Making Prefab Builders Wait

With 755 garden and laneway suites under construction, the program has momentum. Fast-track approvals for factory-built suites, and bring back help for owners who keep rents affordable.

Editorial · By Journal Staff ·
A two-storey grey stucco laneway house with dark-trimmed windows, a dormer and a white garage door, set beside a paved back lane with a large magnolia tree in the foreground
A laneway house in East Vancouver (file photo, 2015), shown for illustration. Photo: Mike / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0 (cropped).

Toronto's backyard housing experiment is finally gaining speed. The city says 755 garden and laneway suites are under construction and 627 permits have been closed, CBC Toronto reported Sunday. That is real progress for a program that started slowly. It is also nowhere near enough for a city this size, and the people trying to build these homes are telling city hall what is getting in the way. Toronto should listen.

From a trickle to a steady flow

Council made laneway suites legal as of right in 2018 and garden suites in 2022, pitching them as a way to add homes in established neighbourhoods while letting owners earn rental income or house relatives. For years, uptake was thin. In July 2025, Mayor Olivia Chow said only 166 laneway suites and 114 garden suites had been completed, and conceded that zoning changes alone had not spurred enough construction. The city responded with free, pre-approved suite designs and extended its engineer's-seal fast-track program to laneway and garden suites.

It has helped. City figures reported by CBC show garden suite building permits went from 34 in 2022 to a total of 361 by 2025. Credit belongs to council and staff for sticking with an idea that looked like a dud.

The new bottleneck: building differently

The trouble now is that the system rewards owners who build the old way. Nitin Goela and Joanne Magday, who are putting a garden suite in their backyard, chose panelized construction, where walls and floors are made in a factory and trucked in. That choice, they told CBC, brought more scrutiny from the city and "a lot more back and forth." Minesh Dattani, president of Prefab Builds Canada, said prefab is faster and easier to get onto tight lots, and his projects meet the Ontario Building Code, but municipal approvals have not caught up. He wants the city to work with builders on "a workflow which is so much more efficient."

The city's answer is reasonable on its face: proposals that aren't pre-approved take time because staff must check specific materials, assemblies and methods against the code. But that is precisely why a one-off review of the same factory product, lot after lot, makes no sense. Toronto already pre-approves suite designs. It should do the same for manufactured systems: review a builder's panels or modules once, then let them move through permitting like any pre-approved plan. The industry has asked for something like this before. In 2025, Resimate founder Sarah Cipkar urged the city to make its free designs available to manufacturers who could build them off site.

Money still decides who builds

Red tape is only half the problem. Cipkar put the cost of a typical project at $200,000 to $350,000. The city charges no development charges for the second through sixth homes on a single lot and offers a 20-year deferral program. But its Affordable Laneway Suites Program has been discontinued because of insufficient provincial funding and is not expected to return.

That matters. University of Toronto geographer Susannah Bunce warned that without help such as a rebate or forgivable loan, owners have every reason to recoup their costs with high rents. When CBC asked this month whether grants were on the table, the province did not reply and Ottawa did not address the question. Queen's Park or Ottawa should fund a modest forgivable loan for owners who agree to keep rents affordable.

Keep the neighbours in the picture

Growth also brings friction. In Danforth-Greenwood, neighbours have campaigned against a two-storey garden suite they say took their privacy and light. The city has said such concerns do not, on their own, justify withholding a permit for a code-compliant project. It is right not to reopen the door to case-by-case vetoes. But staff should report to council on whether height and window rules for suites are working, so support for the program doesn't erode one backyard at a time.

No one should oversell what these suites can do. As U of T planning professor Matti Siemiatycki put it, the current numbers are "not nothing, but it's not solving the housing crisis in a city this size." Still, every suite is a home that didn't need a new tower or a new subdivision. Toronto has finally got owners interested. Now it should stop making the fastest builders wait the longest.

Sources: CBC News (Nov. 15) · CBC News (Nov. 2) · CBC News (July 4, 2025) · CBC News (July 6, 2025) · City of Toronto (Laneway and Garden Suite Development Charges Deferral Program) · City of Toronto By-law 845-2025