Sunday, November 22, 2026Toronto, ON
The Toronto Journal
Editorial

Editorial: Ford's Own Panel Said Councillors Could Hold a Third of Toronto Hydro's Board. Bill 140 Should Say the Same

Schedule 16 would strip council's three voting seats and leave Toronto one non-voting observer, going further than the PULSE report. Queen's Park can modernize utility boards without shutting out the city that owns them.

Editorial · By Journal Staff ·
Toronto Hydro's Substation D, a three-storey red-brick building with arched windows and decorative brickwork, on a downtown street corner at Duncan and Nelson streets, with glass condo towers rising behind it under a blue sky
Toronto Hydro Substation D at Duncan and Nelson streets downtown (file photo, April 2026). Photo: Dillan Payne / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 (cropped).

Toronto city council did two things on Thursday that, under a bill now moving through Queen's Park, could soon contradict each other. It named Councillors Rachel Chernos Lin and Mike Layton, along with Coun. Neethan Shan as the mayor's designate, to the board of Toronto Hydro. And it adopted Mayor Olivia Chow's motion affirming the utility's public ownership and opposing Bill 140's governance changes. If the Ford government's Building Ontario Faster Act passes as written, none of the three would be allowed to sit on the board.

The province's case deserves a fair hearing. Ontario's 58 local electricity distributors face what the Electricity Distributors Association forecasts could be up to $120 billion in distribution investments over the next two decades. Energy Minister Stephen Lecce argues the bill is about competence, not ownership: “There’s no change to the ownership model of utilities. We’re changing the people who sit on the boards”. Skilled, independent directors are a reasonable goal for a company that has to rebuild a growing city's grid.

The bill goes further than the government's own experts

The trouble is that Bill 140 does not follow the advice it cites. The government's Panel for Utility Leadership and Service Excellence, known as PULSE, recommended that municipal elected officials and their delegates make up no more than one-third of a utility's board, so that a majority of directors would be independent. That is a sensible middle ground. Schedule 16 of the bill instead would bar mayors, councillors and municipal officers and employees from being appointed as directors at all, leaving each municipal shareholder one non-voting, uncompensated board “participant”. The law firm Aird & Berlis put it plainly: the ban is more restrictive than PULSE.

For Toronto, that means council's three board positions are removed, with only one remaining and without voting rights, according to the mayor's motion. The Association of Municipalities of Ontario, which supports parts of the package, warned that limiting municipalities to one non-voting board member who would be barred from certain discussions would significantly weaken the municipal voice even where a city keeps majority ownership.

Why the ownership worry isn't paranoia

Lecce says privatization “is not what we’re contemplating today”, and the bill itself would not force municipally owned utilities to accept private shareholders. But the same PULSE report says that for large utilities, pension plans and strategic energy investors expressed strong interest in direct equity participation with a consistent preference for majority ownership. It also says potential equity investors place a high value on clear governance, independent decision-making and alignment of fiduciary responsibilities. Read together, it is fair for Torontonians to ask whether clearing councillors off the board is the first step toward something bigger.

Toronto has also put real money behind its utility. In 2024, council committed $1.3 billion over ten years for infrastructure upgrades, including $300 million in direct equity and letting the utility keep $1.017 billion in dividends. Last year, Toronto Hydro paid $60 million in dividends to the city. In June, council voted 21 to 1 to amend the shareholder direction so the utility cannot raise equity from anyone other than the city unless council directs it.

What Queen's Park should do

The fix is not complicated. Amend Schedule 16 to match the one-third cap the province's own panel recommended, so cities keep voting seats while independent directors hold the majority. Push back the proposed Jan. 1, 2027, deadline for rebuilding boards, which Aird & Berlis says may be quite challenging given the shareholder agreements, recruitment and new rules involved. And put the government's assurance into law: any sale of an equity stake in a municipal utility should require a vote of the council that owns it.

The bill was introduced one day after the municipal elections, and council says it was not consulted. Comments on the related regulations are due Nov. 30. That leaves a little time to get this right. If Queen's Park means what it says about ownership, it should have no trouble writing that down.

Sources: Canada's National Observer (Nov. 19) · City of Toronto: Mayor's agenda item on Toronto Hydro (Nov. 19) · The Public Gallery: Toronto council live summary (Nov. 19) · Government of Ontario: PULSE panel report · Ontario Newsroom (Oct. 27) · Aird & Berlis (Nov. 3) · Toronto Star (Lecce response) · Association of Municipalities of Ontario (updated Nov. 19) · City of Toronto: Council item 2026.EX32.5 (June vote) · Legislative Assembly of Ontario: Bill 140